These are great points. I feel as though we didn't use the workshop well. I also feel as though we were never prepped and told it is fine to say negative things about anthers piece. I know that i personally feel to insignificant to give feedback sometimes. While I may have my opinion on what i think will sound better I am unable to voice it because I feel as though I have no right to tell another person how they should write or what is better. Expression is individual. At the same time We all novices in poetic language. I would be silly giving inadequate advice due to my limited knowledge.
At the same time I myself feel a lot better and see new things when others give negative critiques of my work. I feel as though much of the advice is quite helpful in opening my eyes to something that could improve my poem. I also feel as though more input decreases the likelihood of having a bad piece. When all put their heads together something better can be made than if one mind and one perspective were to lone work at it.
when all is said and done I agree and everyone should lose their fear and voice what they think about others poems. I just know why it is hard.